Drake + J. Cole or Drake vs. J. Cole?

PSA: This is not news. News, journalism, is objective. What I am about to tell you is not in the least bit objective.

How do I feel about this announcement from XXL Magazine? If you asked my colleagues, they'd probably tell you I have mixed feelings. And they'd be right.

I hate Drake. Do I think he is talented? Yes. Do I think he is brilliant? Without a doubt. He's made a name for himself (and millions of dollars) by being unabashedly himself. I cringed the whole through my first viewing of his "Hotline Bling" music video, but I do have to admit it was a brilliant move. I cannot think of any other artist making that same video and having it work in his or her favor. But all he did was a funny dance? Yeah, pretty much.

Musically, I do not listen to Drake for substance, for feeling or quality rap music. (I listen because I like to be in the loop. Should I have included a trigger warning for y'all? Sorry.) But his songs are so heartfelt, right? Disgustingly so, yes, and I doubt he's really had any hardships in his life that inspire these rap ballads other than maybe playing the role of a handicapped teenager in DeGrassi.

But he makes hits, you say? Who cares! If I thought "hits" were an artist's only valuable criteria then I would be listening to the radio, not SoundCloud.

Yet the reason I am so ambivalent about this news is not so much because I dislike Drake with a passion, but because I am completely and hopelessly enamored by J. Cole. (Go check out my first review and see why.) I think he may be one of, if not the most, talented and hardworking rapper in the game. Even the quietly released Revenge of the Dreamers II, a Dreamville collaboration album, had me in awe. While he may not be releasing music as frequently as Future, he has a way of catching me by surprise with tracks like "Black Friday," releasing a live version of 2014 Forest Hills Drive on his birthday this year and producing both a personal, behind the scenes miniseries and a live concert documentary on HBO.

If anything, I think Drake would benefit from working with Dreamville and J. Cole. J. Cole could teach Drake a thing or two about making music that means something, not just music that appeals to the masses. Drake fans may argue that J. Cole could benefit from Drake's wide-ranging appeal and popularity. But when you're an artist as deep in your bones as J. Cole, adding in Drake's style just seems like poisoning the well to me.

Guest ReviewComment